Base Facility: Research Hospital

“Some civilian workers got in among the research patients today and became so hysterical I felt compelled to have them nerve stapled. The consequence, of course, will be another public relations nightmare, but I was severely shaken by the extent of their revulsion towards a project so vital to our survival.”

— CEO Nwabudike Morgan, The Personal Diaries

This is another one of those awesome quotes that demonstrates the extreme economy that, in a just world, Reynolds should be famous for.  He tells an entire story in just two sentences.  And he does this all the time!

OK, so first let’s tally up the bare facts.  We know Morgan is running a research hospital, since that’s the facility that comes along with the quote.  The hospital consists of at least two main departments: the place the civilian workers are supposed to be and the place they ended up.

The first, where the civilians work, is presumably a hospital along the lines of what we’d be familiar with nowadays.  We already know from the gameplay that doctors are the specialists that yield bonus Psych energy, so that explains why the hospital would serve as a multiplier for Psych spending in the base.

We know precious little about the second.  We can start with the fact that they must be research patients because doctors are trying out new therapies on them.  We also know that it’s supposed to be secret, given the facts that the civilians weren’t supposed to see the research patients.  And, finally, we know that whatever they’re doing in there, CEO Morgan thinks that it’s critical to his faction’s survival.  Which means this is where the bonus to the base’s research is coming from.

We can look to the technology tree to find another couple hints as to what sort of research they’re doing.  The Research Hospital base facility is unlocked by the Gene Splicing technology, which is in turn based upon the Biogenetics and Ethical Calculus technologies from earlier.  So it follows that the research they are doing involves editing the genetic code on living patients and seeing what happens.

If you were to go in and see them, the research patients must necessarily consist largely of the failed experiments.  The workers must have seen countless people behind glass with crippling deformities, weird alien growths, and who knows what else wrong with them.  It must be a house of horrors in there.  No wonder the civilians freaked out so badly the CEO nerve stapled them to get them to chill out and not talk about what they’d seen.

Finally, it’s worth taking a moment to consider the purpose of using CEO Morgan for this quote instead of one of the other faction leaders.  From what we’ve heard about the other factions, we’d expect Zakharov to be unapologetically running a facility like this.  But, by the rules of the game, we know that any faction can build Research Hospitals.  And unless they’re the Believers or running a Fundamentalist government, they all get the same benefit from the research.

Putting this together, we see that in canon, virtually every faction must be getting similar experiments up and running as soon as they can.  Echoing Chairman Yang’s prior claim that to renounce genetic manipulation is to deprive oneself of a tool uselessly, CEO Morgan claims here that the project is vital to the faction’s survival.  That must be because everyone else is doing it and they can’t afford to fall behind.

But it is also interesting that, in private, Morgan is willing to admit to being severely shaken by the extent of the civilians’ revulsion.  I find that an evocative choice of words.  All the leaders in SMAC are usually so philosophically certain as they make their various cases.  But, in this instance, we see Morgan display uncharacteristic doubt in his choices.  He’s thinking that maybe he’s got it all wrong.  And, for comfort, he implicitly turns to the reasoning provided by Ethical Calculus to reassure him that he’s doing the right thing.

As an aside, it’s worth mentioning that in canon, CEO Morgan is almost assuredly running a Free Market economy by this point.  In the game, that comes with a substantial police penalty that prevents the faction from using wide-scale nerve stapling to halt drone riots, at the cost of being considered an international atrocity.  This is a technology that the colonists bring with them from Earth.  The fact that Morgan is able to have a small number of workers nerve stapled shows that nerve stapling must be an accepted form of punishment among all the factions on Planet.

Finally, I find it exceedingly interesting that Reynolds chose CEO Morgan as the character to deliver this quote.  The stereotypical cutthroat capitalist is heartless.  And to this point, Morgan hasn’t done anything to dispel the stereotype.  But here, we get the opportunity to see Morgan display a conscience.  It’s not something you’d necessarily expect from a guy who publishes quotes like “Greed ensures the transfer of power from the weak to the strong.”

All told, this is the plot of a great dystopian sci-fi movie.  Something Charlton Heston would have starred in had it been made in the ’70s.  And the player is getting this as a two sentence aside during his awesome 4X strategy experience!

SMAC is a truly singular achievement.


6 thoughts on “Base Facility: Research Hospital

  1. ramblog

    So who canonically wins? It seems like everyone was around to give a quote.

    Morgan’s reticence is pretty interesting. I appreciate your point that there are no villains in the game, that everyone has a viewpoint and is hardcore in their way.


  2. Sesquame

    “Morgan’s reticence is pretty interesting”

    I always saw it that Morgan believes strongly in “don’t hate the player, hate the game”, and he’ll gladly play to win. But nerve stapling innocent people to cover up state secrets isn’t what you do in the rules-based, voluntary transaction focused Free Market. They don’t have a lot of rules of conduct, but the no-coercion taboos of Objectivists are strong ones. Silencing people is the domain of Moochers and the Statists and Morgan doesn’t like having to violate his own principles for the sake of his faction. Where Andrew Ryan used government power for personal gain and never even realized he had abandoned his ideology, Morgan at least has the decency to feel guilty about it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Nick Stipanovich Post author

      “Don’t hate the player, hate the game” is a really good way of putting Morgan’s mindset. I’m sure he’d agree wholeheartedly.

      Contrasting him with Andrew Ryan from Bioshock is also fascinating. That’s an excellent comparison: they’re two of the only three fictional characters I can think of off the top of my head that simultaneously exercise sovereign authority while being committed Objectivist-libertarians. Libertarians (in real life and in fiction) are usually rebels and rabble-rousers, not the guys running the show.

      In radical libertarian thought, force is typically exercised by the bad guys. The Moochers and Statists, as you say. The good guys always use force only to defend against these intolerable incursions against their sovereign personhood.

      But what happens when you start pushing the boundaries. Is trespassing force? Most would say yes, meaning that it is fair game to shoot trespassers on sight. What about theft? Also yes – property is supposed to be inviolate, right?

      So then what happens when one guy owns a whole city, like Andrew Ryan? Or a whole country, like CEO Morgan? Everybody there is under an access contract (think EULA) that alienates certain rights in exchange for accepting the rental contract. Generally, this involves agreeing to things like submitting to state arbitration of disputes and agreeing to the code of conduct for public places, etc., etc. This makes the social contract all very Lockean and explicit. And it also grants the guy in charge the right to do virtually anything he wants. After all, it’s his theme park. If he wants to enforce the rules strictly and, in doing so, rule it like a tyrant, well, you shouldn’t have clicked through the EULA so fast, Mr. Sovereign Citizen.

      Therefore, the legal and moral justification for Morgan’s actions is undoubtedly that Intellectual Property is Property and deserves all the protections accruing thereunto. If some employees of Morgan Pharmaceutical wandered into the wrong place and threatened to disclose the company trade secrets they thus came into contact with, in express violation of corporate policy, Morgan Industries is therefore justified in preventing the in-progress theft with as much force as is required to prevent the disclosure. Hence the nerve stapling.

      Andrew Ryan’s philosophical position is similar, I’d argue. The big difference is that Morgan never had to deal with an internal rebellion. In SMAC, it’s pretty easy to keep the drones in line. Rapture, on the other hand, fell apart due in large part to Fontaine’s persistent pressure on Ryan’s weak points (both ideological and personal), coupled with the ineffectiveness of Ryan’s response.

      We could happily stop the analysis there. But I think Reynolds’s framework has still more insight to deliver. Consider for a moment the meaning of the Social Engineering screen in this context. Morgan wants to run Free Market because he believes in it. He cannot bring himself to centrally plan the economy under any circumstances. But his philosophy is largely silent on politics. He can run a Police State or a Fundamentalist theocracy without undue violence to his core beliefs (though he probably sheds a single tear for the energy points lost to inefficiency as he does so).

      So the $64,000 question is: what would Morgan have done if he was in Ryan’s place in Bioshock? I don’t know the answer to that question, but it’s really fun to think about.


  3. domain322

    I think you misunderstood Morgan’s point, he was not upset by the inhumane experiments, he was shaken to discover that some of his people are so very upset even though the ends so clearly justify the means to him here. So this is the opposite of showing his uncertainty or compassion.


  4. Nicholas

    “Greed ensures the transfer of power from the weak to the strong.” What’s the source of that one? I must have missed it.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s